When I was an adolescent and teenager, I had a marble notebook that I carried with me everywhere. It was full of truly awful poetry, broody letters, cut-and-pasted items I thought were interesting (or at least made me interesting), and so on. It was, by the parlance of today’s youth, “cringe af.”
I don’t regret it at all. Part of me, in the classic Millenial cliche, is glad it was only a notebook and not eternalized social media posts or videos. But I don’t regret the time in my life when I was… whatever I was.
Cringe is part of growth. Cringe is good. We all try on scores of identities as we explore what makes the world interesting. As we figure out what we truly have to offer, we seek and struggle for something that both sets us apart and includes us. We want to be different, but we want people to notice that we’re different and admire it. Full admission: I would never, ever show anyone that notebook back then, but I always hoped people saw me writing in it and were intrigued by the mystery. I wanted more than anything for someone to want to read that notebook, to care enough about me to try to pry out my secrets.
That actually did happen. But it wasn’t until years and years after I didn’t write in it anymore. I still had it for a long time, a piece of nostalgia maybe. But someone who already knew me and cared about me discovered it in some corner of my closet and then was interested, because by then it was an artifact. Something about who I had been, rather than who I was now – and maybe some sense of the journey from one to the other.
We read it together, and of course it was cringe af. But I enjoyed the reading. I enjoyed seeing that young man’s exploration, trying to figure out what he thought was cool, what he thought other people might think was cool, and reconciling how he felt about both. That young man grew up into a guy that’s pretty sure-footed when it comes to dealing with the opinions of his peers. He became a pretty socially fearless guy, as a matter of fact.
I tossed the old notebook, after that. I don’t put a lot of stock in physical objects like that, and it had now served its full purpose. That part of the journey was over, and I was happy with it. No desire to go back, and no regrets about the time I was there.
Cringe is good. It’s just the sense you get when you try things on and they don’t quite fit yet. But trying things on is all of life, if you want it to be worth living.