When you’re on the more “in demand” side of a transaction, the natural thing to do is put up filters. If you’re posting a job, the entire process is one big filter – designed to get you to the person you want in the role. If you’re a young adult woman posting on a dating site, you’re trying to filter down to the person you find most desirable. If you’re a Dungeon Master who wants to fill a table with geeks for some D&D, you want to filter down to the 3-5 or so that will contribute the best vibes to the campaign.
In all of these cases, people consistently make two major mistakes. More accurately, it’s one major mistake with two distinct sides.
The first (side of the) mistake is this: You can’t get what you want out of life through filtering alone. I can take a pool of job applicants and filter out all but the best one, sure. But the best candidate from that pool might still be a terrible fit, if I didn’t get the right people into the pool to begin with! If your dating strategy is “I will reject all losers,” that’s good – but how are you making sure people other than losers are trying to date you in the first place? You need to hang a little bait out there, is what I’m saying. Your side of the transaction needs to be an example the other party wants to compete for.
The other side of this mistake is all the unintentional filtering we do. If you post a public job ad with a huge list of requirements and qualifications, then in addition to who you want to filter out, you’re also filtering out people who have those qualifications but don’t want to work for unrealistically demanding bosses. If you loudly and publicly shame “losers” who try to date you, then you’re also filtering out people who simply find that attitude distasteful.
(By the way, none of this is a direct criticism of anyone’s choice in criteria for any personal or professional relationship they choose to engage in. Everyone is different, and you do you! I’m just saying to be aware of how you do it because unintended consequences may be working against the very goal you’ve set, whatever it is.)
In sales & marketing, we have this term, “top of the funnel.” That’s the term for everyone who initially engages with your sales & marketing process – so all the people who first engage with a company’s social media might be that company’s “top of the funnel.” Some people won’t make it further and some will, such as clicking on a link within a post, then visiting multiple pages on a website, then buying a product; in this way the “funnel” narrows. At every step, you’re trying to filter even customers; you want to qualify them as being the right customer for you, as being interested, and so on.
But every sales & marketing professional knows a fundamental truth: You want the top of the funnel to be wide open. You’re not trying to gatekeep who can see your initial advertising! Ultimately, you want a large, welcoming pool if you’re seeking a specific individual and don’t know where they are yet.
So throw open your initial gates. Lower the barrier to entry a little, meet some new people, have those initial conversations. They don’t have to go farther than that, but there are some real diamonds in the rough out there. You never know who’s getting caught in the filter that you would wish hadn’t.