Many people seem to have a big blind spot when it comes to reading people. Not just that they can’t do it, but they don’t believe it can be done.
Let’s say two people sit down to play some Texas Hold’em. They decide in advance to play 10,000 hands, because they’re both immortal and don’t need to eat or sleep. The law of large numbers says that over 10,000 hands, pretty much exactly 50% of them will give the better cards to Player A, and the other 50% will give the better cards to Player B. So if “who has the better cards” determines who wins, then the players should come very close to breaking even at the end of the game.
In reality, if one of those people is a professional poker player and the other is not, the pro will absolutely wipe the floor with the amateur.
Why? Does being a professional poker player give you the ability to get dealt better cards from a shuffled deck? Of course not. But the pro will know when his opponent’s hand is better and when his own is, and he’ll bet accordingly. He’ll bait his opponent into bad moves and he’ll maneuver around unbeatable hands. He’ll completely rob the other guy.
And in my experience, at the end of the night, the other guy will say his opponent “got lucky.”
People just absolutely do not like to admit they got tricked, manipulated, or bluffed. They hate the idea of ever losing a battle of wits (probably because we equate being smart with moral worth), to the point where they won’t admit that’s what happened. And as a result, they force themselves to ignore the fact that this is a skill that can be developed.
So the cycle continues. That same person will never be able to read people – or bluff – because they don’t want to acknowledge that other people might already have that skill and be better at it than them.
And I get it. Being tricked, especially outside of a game, feels very bad! And if we acknowledge that we got tricked because of a lack of our own ability to detect the trick in the first place, it’s like taking on the blame, and calling someone else smarter than you. Most people’s egos can’t handle it. Some people won’t even report scams to the police because it hurts their pride too much. If you get robbed at gunpoint, that doesn’t feel as shameful as getting taken in a confidence scheme.
But the only defense against this game is to play it. If you don’t recognize it as real, it’s a huge weak spot. You aren’t immune to it – and if you think you are, you’re even more susceptible. Watch a few poker games, then play a few. It might be frustrating, but it’s a skill worth learning.