A man walks into a therapist’s office. He wants to talk, of all things, about his sports car.
He drives a big, loud, expensive muscle car. It rattles the windows in his neighborhood and costs a ton to maintain, but he drives it all the time. He’s had many different ones and has driven a car like it for years, but lately, some people in his life have been complaining about it and pushing him to drive something more sensible. In a moment of introspection, the man decided to talk to a therapist about it.
The therapist suggests that they should explore why the man drives these cars, as a starting point. So they talk about it a bit. The man opens up, and this is what he admits:
“If I’m really being truly honest, all the way down, I drive these cars to impress women. I’ve never been lucky with the ladies, so I drive these cars as a way to impress dates, flirt, ‘pick up chicks,’ whatever you want to call it. It’s all about that.”
The therapist makes a note, and considers this for a moment before responding. “Has it ever worked? Have you ever impressed a single date, picked up a single woman, or gotten even a flirtatious wink from someone who saw you behind the wheel?”
The man doesn’t have to think long. “Nope, not even once.”
“Why did you start driving these cars? What made you pick this method in the first place?”
The man thinks back, and responds: “I’ve never been great with dating, but a long time ago I was in an especially bad patch. I saw this handsome, funny, rich, smart, confident guy effortlessly pick up a girl he’d been chatting with, and he was driving a sports car. So I bought one to do the same.”
The therapist takes a moment to reflect, and then offers the explanation.
Often people will see a particular action or behavior lead to a certain result in a specific situation. Without a lot of additional context, they’ll adopt that behavior because they want that result, but they miss all the other factors that also contributed to the outcome in that situation. In fact, the behavior they adopt may not even be one of the contributing factors at all – in this case, it’s quite possible that a handsome, funny, rich, smart, confident guy might have done even better without a loud, annoying sports car. Even if that’s not the case, certainly all the other qualities contributed. You can’t just layer one aspect on top of a totally different starting set of circumstances and expect the same results.
Then, pure inertia keeps us committed to that behavior, because we never stopped to evaluate whether we were getting the results we wanted. We take it as a given that the behavior we’ve adopted is contributing to the results we’re seeking because we saw the two correlated. If we’re not getting the results, surely it’s not because of this! And humans are bad at noticing costs. In this case, you didn’t even notice that you don’t even enjoy driving those sports cars. You could have stopped long ago.
If you truly want to be “good with the ladies” – or whatever your goal is – you need to then work backward from that and ask “Is the thing I’m doing to achieve that goal actually getting me closer to it?” And even if you can come up with a scenario where it is, the next question is “Given the cost and effort, is this the best way to get to that goal?”
Let’s call this “The Understanding Turn.” You’re making a turn – a U-turn – around the goal. It’s a simple formula, but requires very deliberate attention:
- “Why am I doing X?” – To get to Y result.
- “Is X actually getting me to Y result?” – Maybe a little, maybe not!
- “If I start from Y result, what’s the best way to achieve it?” – Probably Z!
- Stop doing X, start doing Z.
So much of life is reactive behavior in response to limited information, and that leads us to what turn out to be very strange decisions when examined this way. But taking several large steps back and making the U-turn can put you exactly on the straightest path to your goal.